info@farmcover.co.nz

FMG vs Vero Farm Insurance: Which is Better in 2025?

• 18 min read

FMG and Vero are two of New Zealand's leading farm insurers, but they take very different approaches to rural insurance. This comprehensive comparison examines coverage, pricing, claims service, and real-world performance to help you choose the right insurer for your farm.

Quick Comparison Summary

Feature FMG Vero
Ownership Farmer-owned cooperative Commercial (Suncorp Group)
Specialization 100% rural/farm focus Rural + commercial insurance
Market Share Largest farm insurer (45%) Second in rural (25%)
Pricing Competitive + rebates (2-5%) Often competitive for large ops
Claims Satisfaction 4.2/5 (rural claims) 3.8/5 (rural claims)
Best For Traditional farms, cooperative values Large operations, diversified businesses

Company Profiles: Understanding the Insurers

FMG (Farmers Mutual Group)

Company Background

Founded in 1905 by farmers for farmers, FMG is New Zealand's largest specialist rural insurer with over 120 years of experience. As a farmer-owned cooperative, FMG operates fundamentally differently from commercial insurers - profits are returned to shareholder members rather than external investors.

Key Statistics

  • 65,000+ rural policyholders
  • 45% farm insurance market share
  • $1.2 billion in annual premiums
  • 30,000+ farmer shareholders
  • AM Best rating: A (Excellent)
  • 120+ years in business

Core Values

  • Farmer ownership and control
  • Rural community support
  • Long-term sustainability
  • Specialist expertise
  • Local knowledge and service
  • Mutual benefit model

How the Cooperative Model Works

When you insure with FMG, you can purchase shares and become a co-owner. Shareholders vote on major decisions and board elections, ensuring farmer voices guide company strategy. When FMG is profitable, rebates are distributed to shareholders (typically 2-5% of premiums paid). This model aligns the insurer's interests with farmers' interests - FMG succeeds when farmers succeed.

Product Range

FMG offers comprehensive rural insurance including:

  • Farm property and buildings insurance
  • Farm equipment and machinery insurance
  • Livestock insurance (all types)
  • Rural contractor insurance
  • Horticulture and viticulture insurance
  • Forestry insurance
  • Lifestyle block insurance
  • Farm vehicle and motor insurance
  • Home and contents (rural properties)

Unique Strengths

  • Deepest rural expertise in New Zealand (120+ years exclusive focus)
  • Specialist rural assessors who understand farming operations intimately
  • Strong rural community connections and local agents
  • Farmer-first approach with aligned interests
  • Shareholder rebates reduce effective costs
  • Industry-leading customer satisfaction for rural claims

Vero Insurance New Zealand

Company Background

Vero is a major commercial insurance provider owned by Suncorp Group, one of Australia and New Zealand's largest financial services companies. With strong presence in both rural and commercial insurance, Vero combines rural expertise with commercial insurance strength and international backing.

Key Statistics

  • 35,000+ rural policyholders
  • 25% farm insurance market share
  • $800M+ in rural premiums
  • Part of $15B+ Suncorp Group
  • Standard & Poor's: A+ rating
  • Extensive broker partnerships

Core Strengths

  • Strong financial backing
  • Competitive commercial pricing
  • Digital innovation
  • National assessor network
  • Flexible policy structures
  • Broker access and choice

Commercial Insurance Model

As a commercial insurer, Vero operates to generate profit for shareholders (Suncorp Group). This model emphasizes competitive pricing, efficiency, and broad market coverage. Vero leverages economies of scale and international reinsurance relationships to offer competitive rates, particularly for larger operations. Strong broker partnerships provide farmers with access to market competition and negotiation leverage.

Product Range

Vero offers comprehensive rural and commercial insurance:

  • Rural property and farm buildings
  • Farm plant and machinery
  • Livestock and bloodstock insurance
  • Crop and horticulture insurance
  • Agribusiness and commercial farming
  • Farm vehicle and fleet insurance
  • Public and products liability
  • Business interruption and loss of profits
  • Commercial property (processing, retail, tourism)

Unique Strengths

  • International financial strength and stability (Suncorp backing)
  • Competitive pricing for large commercial operations
  • Excellent for diversified farm businesses with commercial activities
  • Superior digital tools and online management
  • Flexible policy structures for complex risks
  • Extensive broker network providing market access
  • Strong integration with broader commercial insurance needs

Coverage Comparison: FMG vs Vero

Both FMG and Vero offer comprehensive farm insurance coverage. The differences are often in the details, specialist options, and how coverage is structured rather than fundamental gaps.

Coverage Type FMG Vero Winner
Buildings & Property Comprehensive, replacement or sum insured, automatic inflation adjustments Comprehensive, flexible policy structures, commercial property expertise Tie
Farm Equipment Specialist rural machinery coverage, GPS tracking discounts, all risks cover All risks cover, good for high-value specialized equipment, flexible limits FMG
Livestock Extensive dairy, sheep, beef, deer expertise. Stud stock specialists. In-calf/lamb cover. Good livestock coverage, bloodstock specialists, competitive for standard herds FMG
Business Interruption Farm-specific BI calculations, understand seasonal operations, dairy/sheep specialist Strong commercial BI expertise, good for complex/diversified operations Tie
Public Liability $1M-$20M limits, rural-specific liability expertise $1M-$50M+ limits, excellent for agritourism and commercial activities Vero
Crop Insurance Specialist arable, horticulture, viticulture. Strong in Canterbury. Good crop coverage, flexible for diverse cropping operations FMG
Agritourism/Diversification Growing expertise, farm stays, farm shops covered with endorsements Excellent commercial expertise, processing, tourism, retail integration Vero
Forestry Specialist farm forestry coverage, woodlots, commercial forestry options Standard forestry coverage available FMG

Coverage Verdict

FMG wins on: Traditional farming operations, specialist rural knowledge, livestock expertise, and farm-specific coverage nuances.

Vero wins on: Diversified farm businesses, commercial activities, agritourism, high liability limits, and policy flexibility for complex operations.

Tie on: Core coverage breadth - both offer comprehensive protection for standard farm operations.

Pricing Comparison: Real-World Examples

Pricing varies significantly based on individual farm characteristics. These examples are based on 2025 market pricing for comparable coverage levels. Always get personalized quotes for accurate pricing.

Dairy Farm Example

150-Hectare Dairy Farm - Waikato

  • Farm buildings: $2.5M (milking shed, implement shed, hay barn, dwelling)
  • Milking equipment: $800K (rotary shed, vat, cooling system)
  • Livestock: 450 cows valued at $450K
  • Machinery: $600K (tractors, feed out equipment, cultivation)
  • Business interruption: $85K monthly indemnity, 18-month period
  • Public liability: $5M cover
Insurer Base Premium Discounts/Rebates Effective Premium
FMG $28,500 Shareholder rebate: -$855 (3%) $27,645
Vero $27,800 Multi-policy discount: -$834 (3%) $26,966

*Prices exclude GST. Based on comprehensive coverage, $2,500 excess, claims-free for 3+ years. Actual pricing varies.

Verdict: Vero slightly cheaper by $679 (2.5%) for this scenario. Difference is within normal quote variation.

Sheep Farm Example

500-Hectare Sheep Farm - Hawke's Bay

  • Farm buildings: $1.5M (shearing shed, wool shed, hay barns, dwelling)
  • Livestock: 4,000 stock units valued at $400K
  • Machinery: $450K (tractors, implements, farm vehicles)
  • Business interruption: $35K monthly, 12-month period
  • Public liability: $2M cover
Insurer Base Premium Discounts/Rebates Effective Premium
FMG $13,800 Shareholder rebate: -$552 (4%) $13,248
Vero $14,500 Claims-free discount: -$435 (3%) $14,065

*Prices exclude GST. Hill country property, comprehensive coverage, $2,000 excess, no recent claims.

Verdict: FMG cheaper by $817 (6%) for sheep farming. FMG's sheep farming expertise reflected in better pricing.

Arable Farm Example

300-Hectare Arable Farm - Canterbury

  • Buildings & storage: $1.8M (grain storage, workshop, implement sheds)
  • Specialized machinery: $1.5M (harvester, tractor fleet, seeding/spraying equipment)
  • Crop insurance: $800K annual crop value
  • Business interruption: $60K monthly, 18-month period
  • Public liability: $5M cover
Insurer Base Premium Discounts/Rebates Effective Premium
FMG $31,200 Shareholder rebate: -$1,248 (4%) $29,952
Vero $29,500 Large operation discount: -$1,180 (4%) $28,320

*Prices exclude GST. Canterbury region (earthquake loading applied to both), comprehensive coverage including crop insurance.

Verdict: Vero cheaper by $1,632 (5.5%) for large arable operation. Vero competitive for high-value machinery operations.

Pricing Summary

FMG typically more competitive for: Traditional sheep/beef operations, standard dairy farms, farms valuing cooperative model and shareholder rebates.

Vero typically more competitive for: Large commercial operations, high-value machinery operations, diversified farms, and through broker negotiation.

Key takeaway: Pricing differences are usually 5-15% either way. Always get quotes from both for your specific situation. The "cheaper" insurer varies by farm type, size, location, and individual circumstances.

Claims Service Comparison

Insurance value is proven when you claim. Here's how FMG and Vero compare on claims service, based on customer feedback, settlement times, and satisfaction ratings.

FMG Claims Service

Claims Process

  • Specialist rural assessors with farming backgrounds
  • Local claims managers understand regional farming
  • 24/7 claims reporting via phone or online
  • Dedicated rural claims team
  • Proactive communication throughout process

Settlement Times (Average)

  • Equipment claims: 2-3 weeks
  • Livestock claims: 2-4 weeks
  • Building damage (minor): 3-5 weeks
  • Dairy shed claims: 3-4 weeks
  • Major building damage: 8-16 weeks

Customer Satisfaction

  • Overall rating: 4.2/5 for rural claims
  • Assessor knowledge: 4.5/5
  • Communication: 4.1/5
  • Settlement fairness: 4.0/5
  • Speed of settlement: 3.9/5

Strengths

  • Assessors understand farming operations deeply
  • Fair settlements reflecting farming realities
  • Strong rural community relationships
  • Willingness to work with farmers through challenges
  • Higher satisfaction on complex farm-specific claims

Areas for Improvement

  • Settlement can be slower for very complex claims
  • Digital claims tools less advanced than competitors
  • Some delays during peak claim periods (storms, floods)

Vero Claims Service

Claims Process

  • Large national assessor network
  • Commercial and rural assessors
  • 24/7 online and phone claims reporting
  • Advanced digital claims tracking
  • Efficient processing systems

Settlement Times (Average)

  • Equipment claims: 2-4 weeks
  • Livestock claims: 3-5 weeks
  • Building damage (minor): 3-6 weeks
  • Dairy shed claims: 4-6 weeks
  • Major building damage: 8-20 weeks

Customer Satisfaction

  • Overall rating: 3.8/5 for rural claims
  • Assessor knowledge: 3.7/5
  • Communication: 3.9/5
  • Settlement fairness: 3.8/5
  • Speed of settlement: 4.0/5

Strengths

  • Fast processing for straightforward claims
  • Excellent digital claims tools and tracking
  • Large assessor network ensures quick response
  • Strong on commercial/business claims
  • Efficient systems and processes

Areas for Improvement

  • Assessors sometimes lack deep farming knowledge
  • Can feel more "corporate" and less personal
  • Farm-specific nuances occasionally missed
  • Lower satisfaction on complex rural claims

Claims Service Verdict

FMG wins on: Customer satisfaction (4.2 vs 3.8), farming knowledge, complex farm-specific claims, assessor expertise, and farmer relationships.

Vero wins on: Speed of simple claims, digital tools, processing efficiency, and commercial claim expertise.

Bottom line: Both settle claims fairly and efficiently. FMG has an edge on farm-specific claims and customer satisfaction. Vero excels at straightforward claims and digital experience. For traditional farming claims, FMG's specialist knowledge shows. For commercial or standard claims, both perform well.

Pros and Cons: FMG vs Vero

FMG

Pros

  • Farmer-owned cooperative - profits returned via rebates (2-5%)
  • 120+ years exclusive rural insurance expertise
  • Specialist rural assessors with farming backgrounds
  • Higher customer satisfaction (4.2/5 vs 3.8/5)
  • Farmer-first approach with aligned interests
  • Strong rural community connections
  • Excellent for traditional farming operations
  • Voting rights for shareholders on company direction
  • Deep understanding of farming operations and challenges
  • Strong in sheep, dairy, and arable specialist coverage
  • Local rural agents with farming knowledge
  • Fair handling of complex farm-specific claims

Cons

  • Can be more expensive for large commercial operations
  • Less flexible for highly diversified businesses
  • Digital tools less advanced than commercial competitors
  • Shareholder rebates not guaranteed annually (dependent on profits)
  • Smaller assessor network (can mean longer wait in peak times)
  • Less expertise in non-traditional farming activities (agritourism, processing)
  • Limited broker access (mainly direct or FMG agents)
  • Slower claim settlement on very complex cases

Vero

Pros

  • Strong financial backing (Suncorp Group)
  • Often more competitive pricing for large operations
  • Excellent for diversified farm businesses
  • Superior digital tools and online management
  • Flexible policy structures for complex risks
  • Extensive broker network (competitive quoting)
  • Fast processing for straightforward claims
  • High liability limits available (up to $50M+)
  • Strong commercial insurance expertise
  • Good integration with business insurance needs
  • Large national assessor network
  • Efficient claims systems and processes

Cons

  • Lower customer satisfaction for rural claims (3.8/5 vs 4.2/5)
  • Assessors sometimes lack deep farming knowledge
  • Can feel more corporate and less personal
  • No cooperative rebates or profit-sharing
  • Farm-specific nuances occasionally missed in claims
  • Less focus on rural community relationships
  • Can be more expensive for smaller standard farms
  • Specialist rural knowledge not as deep as FMG

Which Should You Choose: FMG or Vero?

The "best" insurer depends on your specific farm, priorities, and circumstances. Use these guidelines to determine which is likely better for you:

Choose FMG if you:

  • Run a traditional dairy, sheep, beef, or arable operation
  • Value the cooperative model and farmer ownership
  • Want specialist rural expertise and assessors who understand farming
  • Prefer working with rural-focused insurers and local agents
  • Appreciate shareholder rebates and voting rights
  • Operate a small to medium-sized farm (100-500 hectares typical)
  • Value higher customer satisfaction and personalized service
  • Have complex farm-specific coverage needs (forestry, specialist livestock)
  • Want an insurer aligned with farming community interests
  • Prefer proven rural claims expertise over corporate efficiency

Choose Vero if you:

  • Operate a large commercial farm (500+ hectares or $5M+ insured values)
  • Run a diversified farm business (agritourism, processing, retail, value-added)
  • Need high liability limits ($10M+) for commercial activities
  • Value competitive pricing and broker negotiation leverage
  • Prefer advanced digital tools and online policy management
  • Need flexible policy structures for complex or unusual operations
  • Want integration with broader commercial insurance (not just farm-specific)
  • Prioritize processing efficiency over specialist rural knowledge
  • Have straightforward insurance needs where pricing is primary factor
  • Value the financial strength of large international insurance groups

Get Quotes from Both if you:

  • Are unsure which model suits you better
  • Have a mixed or complex operation that could suit either
  • Want to see actual pricing difference for your specific farm
  • Are switching insurers and want to compare current coverage
  • Operate a mid-sized farm where either could be competitive
  • Value both specialist expertise AND competitive pricing

Real-World Recommendations

Traditional 150ha Waikato Dairy Farm: FMG likely better. Specialist dairy expertise, competitive pricing with rebates, excellent claims service for dairy-specific issues.

500ha Canterbury Sheep Farm: FMG likely better. Strong sheep farming expertise, competitive for pastoral operations, rural specialist knowledge valuable.

800ha Commercial Arable Operation: Compare both. Vero often competitive for large operations with high machinery values. FMG strong on Canterbury arable experience. Get quotes.

Farm with Agritourism Business: Vero likely better. Stronger commercial insurance expertise, higher liability limits, better integration of tourism activities.

Diversified Farm (Dairy + Processing + Farm Shop): Vero likely better. Commercial expertise for value-added activities, flexible policy structures, high liability coverage.

Small Lifestyle Block (10ha, Few Livestock): Either suitable - compare pricing. Differences minimal for simple lifestyle block coverage.

Frequently Asked Questions: FMG vs Vero

What is the main difference between FMG and Vero farm insurance?

The fundamental difference is ownership structure: FMG is a farmer-owned cooperative where policyholders can become shareholders and receive profit rebates (typically 2-5% of premiums), while Vero is a commercial insurer owned by Suncorp Group. FMG specializes exclusively in rural insurance with 120+ years of farm-specific expertise. Vero offers broader commercial insurance with competitive pricing through extensive broker networks. Both provide comprehensive farm coverage but with different business models and approaches.

Is FMG or Vero cheaper for farm insurance?

Pricing varies by farm type and individual circumstances. Generally: FMG tends to be competitive for standard dairy, sheep, and beef operations, especially when shareholder rebates are factored in (effective 2-5% discount). Vero often offers lower base premiums for larger commercial operations and through broker negotiations. For dairy farms, pricing is typically within 5-10% of each other. For complex or high-value operations, Vero may offer better pricing. Always compare actual quotes for your specific farm rather than relying on generalizations.

Which has better claims service - FMG or Vero?

FMG consistently rates higher in customer satisfaction surveys for rural claims, with specialist rural assessors and deep farming knowledge. Average dairy claims settle in 3-4 weeks, equipment claims in 2-3 weeks. FMG's rural focus means assessors understand farming operations intimately. Vero has efficient claims processing with a large national assessor network, settling straightforward claims quickly (2-4 weeks). For complex farm-specific claims, FMG's specialist knowledge is often advantageous. For standard claims, both perform well. Customer satisfaction ratings: FMG 4.2/5, Vero 3.8/5 for rural claims.

Should I choose FMG or Vero for dairy farm insurance?

For dairy farms, FMG has specific advantages: specialized dairy farm policies with tailored coverage for milking equipment, effluent systems, and dairy-specific business interruption. Deep dairy industry knowledge and assessors who understand dairy operations. Shareholder rebates effectively reduce costs by 2-5%. However, Vero can be competitive for larger dairy operations (300+ hectares) and may offer better pricing for farms with complex risk profiles. Compare quotes from both. FMG is often preferred by dairy farmers who value the cooperative model and specialist expertise. Vero suits farmers prioritizing pricing and broader commercial insurance integration.

Can I get shareholder rebates with FMG insurance?

Yes, FMG operates as a mutual cooperative. When you insure with FMG, you can purchase shares (currently around $5 per share, minimum purchase required). Shareholders receive rebates when FMG is profitable, typically 2-5% of annual premiums. For example, $25,000 in premiums might receive a $625-$1,250 rebate (2.5-5%). Rebates aren't guaranteed annually but have been paid in most recent years. Shareholders also vote on company direction and board members. This cooperative model is unique to FMG among major NZ farm insurers.

Does Vero have better coverage options than FMG?

Both offer comprehensive farm coverage with similar core components (buildings, equipment, livestock, liability, business interruption). FMG offers more specialized rural-specific options like farm forestry coverage, rural contractor insurance, and farm-specific business interruption calculations. Vero provides stronger integration with commercial insurance for diversified farm businesses (agritourism, processing, direct sales) and more flexible policy structures for complex operations. Coverage differences are generally minor - both are comprehensive. The choice depends more on service model, pricing, and specialist expertise than coverage breadth.

Which is better for sheep and beef farms - FMG or Vero?

For sheep and beef operations, FMG typically has an edge due to: specialized understanding of extensive pastoral farming, competitive pricing for standard sheep/beef operations, and strong relationships with the sheep and beef farming community. Vero is competitive for larger sheep/beef operations (1,000+ hectares) and can offer better pricing through broker negotiations. For hill country sheep farms, FMG's rural expertise in assessing terrain and erosion risks is valuable. Compare quotes from both, but many sheep and beef farmers prefer FMG's cooperative model and rural specialization. Price difference typically 5-15% depending on specific farm characteristics.

Is Vero or FMG better for arable farms?

Arable farms can benefit from both insurers differently: FMG offers specialized arable and cropping policies with expertise in crop insurance, harvest equipment, and seasonal business interruption. Strong in Canterbury and other major arable regions. Vero provides excellent coverage for large commercial arable operations, particularly those with significant machinery values ($1M+). Often more competitive for operations with diverse cropping or processing facilities. For standard arable farms (200-400 hectares), pricing is usually competitive between both. For very large operations (500+ hectares) or complex cropping, get quotes from both as Vero may offer better commercial terms.

What are the main advantages of FMG over Vero?

FMG's key advantages: 1) Farmer-owned cooperative with profit rebates to shareholders (2-5% of premiums), 2) Exclusive rural and farming focus with 120+ years specialist expertise, 3) Rural specialist assessors with deep farming knowledge, 4) Strong rural community connections and local agents in farming areas, 5) Higher customer satisfaction ratings for rural claims (4.2/5 vs 3.8/5), 6) Farm-specific policy features and coverage options, 7) Alignment of farmer and insurer interests through cooperative model, 8) Voting rights for shareholders on company direction.

What are the main advantages of Vero over FMG?

Vero's key advantages: 1) Often more competitive base pricing, especially for larger operations, 2) Strong financial backing from Suncorp Group (international scale and stability), 3) Excellent for diversified farm businesses with commercial activities, 4) Flexible policy structures for complex or unusual operations, 5) Superior digital tools and online policy management, 6) Extensive broker network providing negotiation leverage, 7) Good bundling options with broader commercial insurance, 8) Efficient processing and national assessor coverage, 9) Strong commercial insurance expertise for value-added farming operations.

Compare FMG and Vero for Your Farm

Don't choose based on generalities. Get personalized quotes from both FMG and Vero to see actual pricing and coverage for your specific farm. Compare side-by-side and make an informed decision.

Get Free Quotes from Both Insurers

Free, no-obligation quotes • Compare FMG, Vero, and other providers • Expert guidance available